A
Art Kelly
Senior Member
Costa Rica
Spanish
- Dec 30, 2007
- #1
Hi all
I understand the use of preposition past when it means beyond (further than). However, in the above sentence I am not sure about the exactly meaning of past.
E.g. Beyond: past belief
I think I can put beyond instead of past in the sentence. e.g. beyond belief. Now the meaning is more clear to me.
Tegs
Mód ar líne
English (Ireland)
- Dec 30, 2007
- #2
Could you give the context of the phrase please? Otherwise, there is not much anyone can say to help you!
A
Art Kelly
Senior Member
Costa Rica
Spanish
- Dec 30, 2007
- #3
I am sorry but I read this sentence in a grammar chapter and it didn't have any context to give you. This is the reason I didn't understand well the meaning. However the sentence explain the use of the preposition past as beyond.
Tegs
Mód ar líne
English (Ireland)
- Dec 30, 2007
- #4
Ah, ok, in that case, if you are using past as a preposition, it can mean "beyond" in a variety of ways. Here are some examples:
It's past midnight (beyond in time) = it is later than midnight
The shop is past the church (beyond in place) = the church is the first building, then a bit further up the street, there is the shop
He walked past me (move beyond) = he walked on by me
His stupidity is past belief (beyond the scope of, or the limit of, something) = I can believe many things, but his stupidity is beyond the possibilities of even my imagination
I can count past ten in Chinese (beyond in number) = I can count from 1 to more than 10 (up to maybe 20) in Chinese
Does this help?
A
Art Kelly
Senior Member
Costa Rica
Spanish
- Dec 30, 2007
- #5
Many thanks Tegs I understand the meaning of past as a preposition when it means "beyond" better.
T
Thomas Tompion
Member Emeritus
Southern England
English - England
- Dec 30, 2007
- #6
There are two expressions in BE - past belief and beyond belief: they both mean that it's impossible to believe whatever it is that is past or beyond belief.
A
anothersmith
Senior Member
Los Angeles
English, U.S.
- Dec 30, 2007
- #7
Thomas Tompion said:
There are two expressions in BE - past belief and beyond belief: they both mean that it's impossible to believe whatever it is that is past or beyond belief.
And in my experience, in AE "beyond belief" is a more common expression than "past belief." But I have heard both used here.
Macunaíma
Senior Member
Um ninho de mafagalfinhos
português, Brasil
- Dec 30, 2007
- #8
I have a grammar book here that gives the most common collocations with past and beyond:
Past bearing Hope that helps you
Past explaining
Beyond endurance
Beyond belief
Beyond compare
Beyond control
Beyond imagining
rebaco
Senior Member
here and there
Italian
- Jan 29, 2014
- #9
Hi guys.
Just curious about the difference between "past" and "beyond" in this type of sentence:
"Her smile went (past/beyond) his armor and straight to his heart".
Which one is more suitable between the two?
thanks.
P
PatsRule
Senior Member
US English (NYC)
- Jan 29, 2014
- #10
rebaco said:
Just curious about the difference between "past" and "beyond" in this type of sentence:
"Her smile went (past/beyond) his armor and straight to his heart".
Which one is more suitable between the two? thanks.
I would say "Her smile went right through his armor and straight to/into his heart."
If something that was said "went right past him" - means that he missed it, he didn't get it.
If something that was said "was beyond him" - means that it was over his head, he didn't get it.
So... "Her smile went past/beyond his armor and straight to his heart" doesn't make sense to me.
"Her smile went past/beyond his armor" - I would understand that part of the sentence to mean that he missed her smile - he never realized she smiled - he just didn't get it (so it would never reach his heart)
rebaco
Senior Member
here and there
Italian
- Jan 29, 2014
- #11
Thanks!
Really helpful.
I'll go with " through" then.
P
PatsRule
Senior Member
US English (NYC)
- Jan 29, 2014
- #12
rebaco said:
Thanks!
Really helpful.
I'll go with " through" then.
You can also say "Her smile passed right through his armor and straight to his heart"
...and you are very welcome.
You must log in or register to reply here.